From Judge Dave Larson (Ret.) · October 2026

An Open Letter to
Washington Voters

A $1.3 million PAC campaign is misleading Washington voters about this year's judicial races. As a former judge, I won't stay silent while a nonpartisan race is painted as partisan.

Setting the Record Straight

The Full Response, in My Own Words

The mail, texts, and digital ads flooding Washington mailboxes rely on one strategy: convince you that a nonpartisan race is actually partisan, and that electing certain candidates would threaten rights long protected by voters and statute. What follows is my response in full, published here in its entirety.

Dear Washington Voters:

I am committed to voters having more meaningful judicial elections, so I can't stay silent when Washington voters are being misled. As a former judge, I still hold myself to the standard to "act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the independence, integrity, and impartiality of the judiciary."

Special interest groups, including lawyers and public employee unions, want to maintain control over the judiciary in this state. Normally these seats go uncontested, with little attention. This year, so many are contested that voters have a real say in who sits on our state's highest court, and the effects could reach all the way down to our county and municipal courts. That is a threat to their control. They are spending over $1.3 million on a website, texts, and 900,000 mail pieces meant to mislead you, the Washington voter, into treating a nonpartisan race as a partisan one.

A political action committee called "Beware the Attack on Our Courts," was formed and funded by public-sector unions and plaintiffs' trial lawyers. The name itself, with its reference to "our" courts, speaks of the possessory interest they believe they have in the courts. Our courts do not belong to partisan interests. They belong to everyone, regardless of which side of the aisle a voter is on. Keeping these positions nonpartisan on the ballot is the right intent, but there is an active fight today to change that, if not in name, then through perception.

Their main claim is that electing me and the other candidates they oppose would threaten "reproductive freedom, voting rights, worker protections, environmental safeguards and marriage equality." That attack treats the courts as one more branch of government that leans left or right. My promise to voters has been simple: I will decide every case based on the Washington State Constitution, our statutes, and precedent, without fear or favor to any side.

Their messaging is a clear admission that they have used, or expect to use, the courts as a means to an end that serves their own political agenda. The not-so-subtle message is that the candidates they support will further that agenda and the candidates they oppose will not.

Look past the one-liners meant to win votes through emotion over reason, and their claims don't hold up:

Reproductive Freedom

Reproductive freedom was established in Washington State by popular vote in 1970 by Referendum 20, four years before Roe v Wade was decided. Voters reinforced this right in 1991 with Initiative 120. It was not established by a court decision that can be overturned even if a justice is personally against reproductive rights. There are no pending cases that affect reproductive freedom and the right can only be overturned by the legislature or by a majority vote of the people in our state.

Voting Rights

A list of pending voting rights cases shows that they are mostly filed in federal court under federal law. Our justices do not sit as federal judges and have no direct jurisdiction over these cases. Portugal v Franklin County, decided in 2023, is the most recent voting rights case from our Supreme Court.

Worker Protections

Worker protections in our state have been created by state and federal statutes and not by court decisions. Each justice is bound to follow the statutory language. Our Supreme Court has not necessarily been friendly to labor rights. In 2020, they reversed a $2 million-plus damage award to nurses who had their union file suit on their behalf for unpaid overtime. The nurses' individual claims were then initially barred by the statute of limitations leaving them with no recovery. See Washington State Nurses Association v Community Health Systems.

Environmental Safeguards

Environmental protections have been created by federal and state statutes and not by court decisions. Each justice is bound to follow the statutory language. The Washington Attorney General posts a list of pending environmental claims. Only three of thirteen cases were filed in state court. The PAC counts striking down voter-approved I-2066 (Natural Gas Initiative) as an environmental win, the kind of ruling it wants to protect.

Marriage Equality

Same sex marriage was established in Washington State by popular vote in 2012 by Referendum 74. The United States Supreme Court decided Obergefell v. Hodges in 2015. That ruling requires all 50 states to offer same sex marriage. The justices on our state Supreme Court have no authority to overturn that decision and must follow it even if they do not agree.

Influence exerted by PACs is nothing new in politics. However, judicial races are different, especially when lawyers are helping to finance the PACs that are trying to influence the outcome of judicial races.

Comment 1 to Code of Judicial Conduct Rule 4.1 states:

"[A] judge plays a role different from that of a legislator or executive branch official. Rather than making decisions based upon the expressed views or preferences of the electorate, a judge makes decisions based upon the law and the facts of every case."

Our Supreme Court enforces this distinction in Canon 4 of the Code of Judicial Conduct, but it also enforces it in the Rules of Professional Conduct for lawyers.

In their oath, lawyers promise to:

"[A]bide by the Rules of Professional Conduct approved by the Supreme Court of the State of Washington"

They also promise to:

"[M]aintain the respect due to the courts of justice and judicial officers."

In furtherance of the promises they make in their oath, RPC 8.2(a) provides that:

"A lawyer shall not make a statement that the lawyer knows to be false or with reckless disregard as to its truth or falsity concerning the qualifications, integrity, or record of a judge, adjudicatory officer or public legal officer, or of a candidate for election or appointment to judicial or legal office."

More troubling for voters is that their message misleads voters with specific statements about issues and candidates that are false and misleading, in violation of lawyer ethics rule RPC 8.2(a). They also assert that the candidates they oppose have violated ethics rules by prejudging litigation that could come before the court.

I do not have the space to lay out all the ethics provisions that they allege would be violated, but their world view is that judges are supposed to protect the interests of their benefactors in violation of ethics rules. They also ignore the fact that any judicial officer who has a strong opinion or belief in a topic before the court must ethically recuse themselves and never hear the case.

Although the First Amendment protects free speech, those protections are not limitless. Many point to Republican Party of Minnesota v. White, 536 U.S. 765 (2002) as the case that stands for the proposition that First Amendment rights are not lost during judicial campaigns, but it did not give lawyers or judges a green light to make false or misleading statements in judicial campaigns. Ironically, ten of us are running this year for seats on the very institution that adopted and is charged with enforcing RPC 8.2(a).

Their mail also asks you to view a nonpartisan office through a partisan lens, pinning the MAGA label on candidates it simply doesn't fit.

If you've seen these claims, ask yourself how they could be true of someone like me:

  • Served successfully for 18 years on the bench with high ratings
  • Endorsed by the area president of the NAACP for Alaska, Oregon, and Washington
  • Rated Exceptionally Well Qualified by the Loren Miller Bar Association, Washington's bar association of Black lawyers, in 2020, amid the national reckoning after George Floyd's murder, and again in 2024
  • Worked successfully with Democratic legislators in Olympia for 17 years
  • Twice received the President's Award from the District and Municipal Court Judges Association (2018 and 2026)
  • Received the Judge William Nevins Award from the Washington Judges Foundation in 2014 for my role in civics education, nominated by Justice Madsen
  • Awarded the Key to the City by a Democratic mayor in 2025
  • Named best city leader in 2022 by readers of the local paper
  • Twice named Hero of Federal Way Public Schools (2018 and 2022)

Andrew Yang, who ran for president as a Democrat in 2020 and co-founded the Forward Party in response to our divided politics, vetted me and said in a May 28, 2026 Press Release that:

"Dave Larson is exactly the kind of candidate the Forward Party was created to support, and we are proud to stand behind him."

Krist Novoselic, co-founder of the Cascade Party and former bass player for Nirvana, says:

"Dave Larson embodies the type of elected official we need in our state right now, trusted, reasoned, calm, smart, and committed to serving people and not ruling people."

You can see my commitment to serving others on my webpage and watch and listen to my messages here.

I have stayed true to my TVW video voter guide statement that:

"Everyone deserves to have trust and confidence in our Supreme Court regardless of their political beliefs, economic status, or geographic location. One-sided justice for only some of us means that there is no justice for any of us."

I have lived up to my commitment in the Voters' Guide by:

"[Reaching] out to Democrats, Republicans, Labor, Business, and voters across Eastern and Western Washington, because justice that serves only some of us serves none of us."

The unspoken rule in Washington State is that judicial candidates may only seek support from certain interest groups and political parties. Seeking support outside the established interests that want to control our judicial system has long been considered politically unwise, but I refuse to compromise my ethics to appease them, regardless of the consequences.

That unspoken rule was spoken aloud recently when Ian Birk asked Sean O'Donnell to reject support from Republicans but not from Democrats or the special interests who finance the PAC. There was hope when sixty-two judges from across the state answered with a letter saying bipartisan support "is something to be celebrated rather than demonized." Judge O'Donnell has now been punished for it, labeled a threat to the political agenda of the groups who have controlled, and still want to control, your courts.

Someone could file a complaint with the Washington State Bar Association against the lawyers who financed the PAC, but:

  1. The same Bar Association that would investigate a complaint under RPC 8.2(a) featured my opponent on the front cover of its official publication with a favorable feature story while voters had their ballots in hand for the primary.
  2. Candidates supported by the PAC are endorsed by the very Supreme Court justices who regulate the Bar Association that investigates complaints.
  3. Those same justices would decide the merits of any disputed complaint and can reverse any adverse decision made by the Bar.
  4. Many of the lawyers who helped finance the PAC have made direct campaign contributions to the justices who would decide the complaints against them.

This is why I fight. You deserve better than this.

We are at a crossroads with our profession. One road leads to a judicial branch that truly serves the people as the independent, co-equal third branch of state government. The other leads to a future where powerful interest groups continue to dominate the courts and the judicial selection process in a way that invites opposing interests to do the same.

The question for you at the ballot box this year is which path you want judges, lawyers, and the justice system to take. Look past the misleading information being spread and send a message to those who have controlled the courts for far too long by voting the opposite of what they recommend.

Dave Larson signature
Judge Dave Larson (Ret.)
Candidate, Washington State Supreme Court · Position 5
Judge for yourself

Hear it from Dave directly

Review the full record and watch Dave's own messages to voters before you fill out your ballot.